Comment
Your doubting of the word of the man is simply disrespect which is the root of all that is false in science.

Response
Asking for citations is essential to good science. And I note that the person questioned didn't seem to consider it an improper or disrespectful question.

His word was never in doubt. He said something. Fine. He did not say that _he_ had discovered the trees and performed the tests. He had heard about this from elsewhere. I ask about the 'elsewhere' so as to be able to look in to the details. If you are a scientist, this is something you _want_ people to do. Nodding their heads and saying that's nice is about the worst possible response.

'This is true, take my word for it.' is a terrible travesty of science. You may be a fine, honest, careful scientist. But even the finest, most honest, most careful scientist makes mistakes. That's why the fine, honest, careful folks _want_ other fine honest, and careful folks to test their work, to challenge it, and to try to improve upon it.


Return to science notes index
Return bobg main page
Send message to Robert Grumbine